MONTHLY NEWSLETTER

Civic Discourse: Beyond Good Manners

By Vickie Deppe


Earlier this year, I was privileged to attend the Colorado Conference on Civic Discourse presented by the Center for the Study of Government and the Individual at the University of Colorado in Colorado Springs. The keynote address, “Common Ground: A Civil Conversation,” was delivered by Drs. Cornel West and Robert P. George. If you’re even vaguely aware of these two distinguished and prolific scholars, you know that they’re about as far apart politically as any two people can be…and yet the best of friends.

In this wide-ranging discussion, West and George explore the values necessary for true civic engagement:

  • Intellectual humility: I’m wrong about some things, and I don’t know which things I’m wrong about.
  • Openness: having my beliefs challenged is the only way to free myself from falsehood.
  • Courage: articulating an unpopular opinion can jeopardize my standing in communities I care about.

This session is an important listen for everyone in the public arena, both elected officials and advocates…especially those of us in the supermajority world of state-led constitutional reform. I hope you are both encouraged and challenged by Drs. West and George.



Article V News 

Wolf Pack (formerly Wolf-PAC) has rebranded. Their new website is fightcorruption.us.

Art da Rosa of Rigby, Idaho has penned a hopelessly inaccurate op-ed on Article V for the Idaho Dispatch. We highlight the piece not to promote it, but as an example of the ubiquity of mis- and disinformation regarding Article V. Rigby, for example, conflates applications for a convention with both “proposed amendments” (the product of a convention) and their ratification (“Had 38 states voted on it…”). He also introduces new and undefined terminology: “cleared by Congress.” This is why it’s so important to seek information from reputable sources. The State Legislators Article V Caucus recommends scholars and activists on both the left and the right, such as Michael Farris, JD, LLM; Prof. Lawrence Lessig of Harvard Law School; Senior Fellow in Constitutional Jurisprudence Prof. Robert Natelson; the National Constitution Center; the many experts who have addressed the National Federalism Commission; and educational materials for state legislators (as well as the general public) available from Path To Reform and Wolf Pack.

The National Federalism Commission (formerly the Phoenix Correspondence Commission) will meet on September 19. If you are a state legislator and would like to learn more about representing your state at the NFC, please contact Executive Director W. Bruce Lee.

Article V Legislative Activity

Editor’s note: most states have been in recess. No Article V legislation has moved this month.


Article V Legislative Activity

Convention of States Project

  • Illinois: SJR 27 and HJR 15 remain pending in their respective committees. The House version has bipartisan support.
  • Ohio: SJR 3 and HJR 2 remain pending in their respective committees.
  • Pennsylvania: HR 125 remains pending the House State Government Committee. The measure includes delegate selection and oversight language and has bipartisan support.

Countermand

  • Pennsylvania: SR 118 remains pending in the State Government Committee. The legislation also contains language pertinent to delegates, so it is also included in the DSO list below.

Equal Rights Amendment

  • North Carolina: S 438 and H 500 remain pending in their respective committees.

Fiscal Responsibility

  • United States: HCR 15 remains pending in committee.

Free and Fair Elections (Wolf Pack)

There is no Wolf Pack legislation active at this time.

Term Limits

  • United States Congress: HJR 12 and SJR 1 remain pending in their respective committees. The House rendition has bipartisan support.
  • United States Congress: HJR 29, allowing the president to serve a third term under certain circumstances, remains pending in Judiciary.
  • Georgia (in recess): SR 23 continues to await action in the House Rules Committee.
  • Pennsylvania: HR 21 continues to await a hearing in the State Government Committee. The measure covers Supreme Court justices as well as members of Congress and has bipartisan support.

Delegate Selection and Oversight

  • New York: A 8935 remains pending in the Governmental Operations Committee.
  • North Carolina: H 214 remains pending in the Committee on Rules and Operations of the Senate.
  • Ohio: HB 67 and SB112 continue to await action in their respective committees.
  • Pennsylvania: SR 117, specific to a convention to propose a countermand amendment, has been introduced and assigned to committee (see also Countermand legislation, above).

Rescission

No rescission legislation is active at this time.


Constitution Boot Camp  

We finished up the Constitution Boot Camp last month, so we would now like to recommend some extra-constitutional material for your reading pleasure. This month’s recommendation is American Covenant by Yuval Levin.



Who Said it?

The states are not agents of the federal government.

Adrian Fontes, Arizona Secretary of State