Confidence in Most Institutions at or Near Long-Term Lows
Vickie Deppe
Gallup has released its latest polling on Americans’ confidence in 14 institutions. Twelve of the 14 are at a statistical dead heat with their respective all-time lows since Gallup began this survey in 1993. This marks the fifth consecutive year in which the average is below 30%. What’s interesting about this data—besides how consistently dissatisfied Americans are with all three branches of the federal government—is that some of the institutions in which we have the least confidence are those not in the business of governance, yet most frequently seen as politicized: education, big business, and news media. Gallup concludes: “A key factor in this slump is that Americans no longer appear to share a broad faith in core civic, social and government institutions; instead, their confidence varies with who holds political power.”
What does this have to do with Article V? In any scenario, the more stakeholders involved and the farther from home control is exercised, the more competing interests in the mix and the less satisfied people are going to be. Local control, on the other hand, maximizes people’s sense of humanity and agency. I’ve often joked that state representatives are more responsive than members of Congress because state reps know they might run into a constituent at the grocery store. Humorous anecdotes aside, the Gallup data bear this out: with a confidence rating between 43% and 64%, local police have consistently—and perhaps surprisingly—been rated among the highest of these institutions. Local business has maintained a confidence rating at or near 67%. Even at its low point, small business enjoyed the confidence of well over half the respondents.
The three non-governing “biggest losers”—education, big business, and the news—are federally regulated, subsidized, or both. The federal government is a creation of the states. The states have the right to reimagine this relationship, as well how the environment in which these entities operate can be structured to better serve constituents. They can realize these improvements at an Article V Convention.
Article V News
Factually has published What Majority Is Required in Congress to Propose a Constitutional Amendment Under Article V Though some of the links don’t work, the basic information that is presented is reliable and has been sourced from reputable entities such as the National Constitution Center, Justia, and the National Archives.
Vince Stango and Julie Silverbrook call for a renewed commitment to civic education and participation in The Fulcrum.
Article V Legislative Activity
Convention of States Project
- Massachusetts: HB 5422 remains pending in the Rules Committee.
- Michigan: HCR 7 remains pending in the Senate Government Operations Committee.
- New Jersey: SCR 32 remains pending in the Senate State Government, Wagering, Tourism, and Historic Preservation Committee. The measure has bipartisan support.
- New York: C 1002 died in committee.
- Ohio: SJR 3 and HJR 2 remain pending in their respective committees.
- Pennsylvania: HR 125 remains pending in the House State Government Committee. The measure includes delegate selection and oversight language and has bipartisan support.
Countermand
- Pennsylvania: SR 118 remains pending in the State Government Committee. The legislation also contains language pertinent to delegates, so it is also included in the DSO list below.
Equal Rights Amendment
Fiscal Responsibility
- United States: HCR 15 remains pending in the House Judiciary Committee.
- South Carolina: S 1164 remains pending in the Judiciary Committee. In addition to applying for the convention, it provides for state action if Congress fails to act on the call and offers Charleston, SC as host.
Free and Fair Elections (Wolf Pack)
Term Limits
- United States Congress: HJR 12 and SJR 1 continue to remain pending in their respective committees. The House rendition has bipartisan support.
- United States Congress: HJR 29, allowing the president to serve a third term under certain circumstances, continues to remain pending in Judiciary.
- Pennsylvania: HR 21 continues to await a hearing in the State Government Committee. The measure covers Supreme Court justices as well as members of Congress and has bipartisan support.
Delegate Selection and Oversight
- Michigan: HCR 2 and HB 5151 have been reported out of committee with recommendation and without amendment. Both await second reading.
- Missouri: SB 1119 has been signed by the Governor.
- New Jersey: S 832 continues to await action in the Senate State Government, Wagering, Tourism, and Historic Preservation Committee.
- North Carolina: H 214 continues to await action in the Committee on Rules and Operations of the Senate.
- Ohio: HB 67 and SB112 continue to await action in their respective committees.
- Pennsylvania: SR 117 continues to await action in the State Government Committee (see also Countermand legislation, above).
- South Carolina: S 1163 continues to await a hearing in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Compact for a Safe and Equal Convention for Proposing Constitutional Amendments
- South Carolina: S 1165 continues to await action in the Judiciary Committee.
Rescission
- Alaska: HJR 41 continues to await action in the Judiciary Committee.
Other
New Jersey: SCR 22, applying for a convention to propose a balanced budget amendment, a term limits amendment, and unspecified changes to the allocation of Electoral College votes, continues to await a hearing in the Senate State Government, Wagering, Tourism, and Historic Preservation Committee.
Constitutional Education
The National Constitution Center has rolled out Constitution 101, a series of brief videos accompanied by recommended reading that may be completed at one’s own pace. The series finale covers Article V and the 27 amendments that have been ratified since the adoption of our Constitution.
Who Said it?
[S]elf-government always requires renewal … Every generation must learn it, practice it, strengthen it, and pass it on.
Vince Stango & Julie Silverbrook