Remembering Stu MacPhail
Donald “Stuart” MacPhail, a leader within the national Article V movement and former editor of the State Legislators Article V Caucus Newsletter, passed away peacefully at his home on September 28th, 2024. The State Legislators’ Article V Caucus would like to extend our deepest sympathy and condolences to the MacPhail family.

Stu was a friend, colleague, and gentleman, always with the insights of an elder statesman. As the long-time editor of this publication, he shared news and views of the state’s ability to propose amendments and advocated for a balanced budget amendment. Everything Stu touched was made better, as a husband, father, grandfather, and adventurer. He was always on the move, traveling our country and the world. He will be missed.
~ NEAL SCHUERER, Caucus Steering Committee Member and Former Iowa State Senator
Stu was a significant political force for the Article V movement. His work preparing monthly reports for the State Legislators Article V Caucus for over a decade helped educate and encourage state legislators and others all across our country. We will miss his always positive encouragement and wise counsel. He will also be remembered for his work as the Public Relations director for Rockmont College in the early 60’s where he was instrumental in moving the college to the campus which is now the home of Colorado Christian University.
~ KEVIN LUNDBERG, Caucus Steering Committee Member and Former Colorado State Senator
Well-wishers may visit Stu’s memorial page here. Learn more about the State Legislators Article V Caucus here.
Hysterical
By Vickie Deppe
David Super has penned the hysterical “An Article V Constitutional Convention Would Supercharge Project 2025”…and by “hysterical,” we mean “unhinged from rational thought.” Whether Prof. Super is ignorant or deliberately withholding key facts, there’s nothing funny about someone like this having influence over our next generation of legal thinkers—especially one who is ensconced at Georgetown Law, one of the most prestigious law schools in the country.
Super disingenuously claims that Republicans “could write amendments as they saw fit without any need to compromise with Democrats or independents,” conveniently ignoring the fact that anything that emerges from a convention for proposing amendments must be ratified by at least 3/4 (currently 38) of the states. With control of 19 state legislatures plus one chamber in a 20th, Democrats would be comfortably able to prevent the ratification of any amendment. This is extremely unlikely to change in January.
Super also asserts that if Republicans maintain their majority in the House and gain control of the Senate, Congress “likely will seek to call an immediate Article V convention.” History and human nature tell us otherwise: a convention to propose a Balanced Budget Amendment had the requisite applications from 2/3 of the states for 43 years beginning in 1979 and as recently as 2021. While those applications were in force, Republicans controlled both chambers of Congress for 17 years, yet failed to call the convention. Why? Because a convention for proposing amendments is meant for a time when, as George Mason sagely predicted, “the Government should become oppressive.” Congress doesn’t want reforms imposed on it from the outside (who does?). Its habit of circumventing state-initiated reform by proposing amendments or legislation of its own goes all the way back to the Bill of Rights and continues as recently as the Graham-Rudman-Hollings Balanced Budget Act.
Opponents of state-led constitutional reform must routinely resort to these sorts of histrionics to frighten the uninformed. They can’t tell the truth because the truth is, they don’t trust the Constitution or We the People.
Article V News
A convention for proposing amendments is a winning issue on both sides of the aisle: a Susquehanna Poll commissioned by Convention of States Action shows that 71% of respondents believe the federal government has too much power and 68% support a convention for proposing amendments as articulated by the Convention of States Project application. 59% indicated that they trusted their state legislators more than their Congressional counterparts. Notably, 38% of the respondents identified themselves as Democrats, 37% as Republicans, and 24% as independent or unaffiliated voters.
AMAC has picked up a piece by Rob Natelson, “How a Convention of States Really Works.” In it, Natelson explains the process, refutes misinformation, and provides numerous links for readers who want to learn more.
If you can’t get enough Natelson, you’re in luck! Law & Liberty has published “Busting the Myths About Article V Conventions,” a historical overview of conventions in America that debunks the “we can’t possibly know what will happen” scare tactic.
“States Need to Assert Their Rights Under Article V of the Constitution” by Ken Cuccinelli, former Attorney General of Virginia, and David Walker, former Comptroller General of the United States, was picked up by DC Journal, The Daily Courier, and River Reporter.
Article V Legislative Activity
A Convention of States Project application has emerged from committee in Pennsylvania. A Delegate Selection and Oversightmeasure remains in committee in the New Jersey Senate. Companion legislation was filed and assigned to committee in the Assembly. A noteworthy feature of the New Jersey DSO package is the requirement that delegates “have relevant subject matter expertise in areas that may include, but may not be limited to, constitutional law, civics, rules of order, American history, political science, political theory, and government.”
Constitution Boot Camp
Are you working through the Constitution with your colleagues across the nation? This month we’ll be looking Article III: The Federal Courts, beginning on page 20.
Who Said It?
…an implicit premise of the Constitution [is] that the diversity of interests and views in American society is a permanent reality. Our politics does not exist to extinguish that multiplicity but to allow us to live together, seek the good, and address public problems in the midst of it.
Yuval Levin, American Covenant