Washington Has Too Much Power
By Vickie Deppe
A new Gallup survey reports that a record-breaking 62% of Americans think the federal government has too much power. Half or more respondents have agreed that “the government has too much power” for two decades now, no matter who was in the Oval Office or which party controlled Congress. What unifies us even more is that throughout these two decades, no more than 9% have said that the federal government “does not have enough power;” and in most years, the majority of respondents report that the government is “doing too much.”
This news comes just as Congress has once again shut down the government, leaving federal employees without a paycheck and everyday Americans unable to do things like renew a passport or visit federally administered facilities (facilities our tax dollars support) like the National Zoo. Though Social Security and Medicare funds will continue to be disbursed, officials warn that SNAP benefits could be in jeopardy beginning this month.
Whether you hold Republicans or Democrats responsible for this state of affairs, surely we can all agree that Congress should not be in a position to take Americans—especially the most economically vulnerable Americans—hostage in order to advance a political agenda. The reason they can is because Washington has too much power. The good news is that the Constitution gives the states a mechanism to rebalance power when things get out of hand. Do you think things have gotten out of hand? Use that energy to sponsor an application for an Article V Convention to impose reforms on Congress that we all know they’ll never undertake on their own. Surveys consistently show that your constituents trust you a lot more than they trust your congressional counterparts.
Article V News
PBS has released a new video short in its Civics Made Easy series. “Is a New Constitutional Convention Around the Corner?” explores both the history leading up to the 1787 Convention and the contemporary movement to call a convention to propose amendments under the authority of Article V. We are gratified that the Article V movement has gained enough traction that PBS thinks it worthy of attention. That being said, while the piece features interviews with both Virginia Kase Solomón of Common Cause and Mark Meckler of Citizens for Self-Governance, the producers are obviously sympathetic to the “anything could happen” scare tactics promulgated by convention opponents. Perhaps this is because PBS is a federally-funded entity. To learn more about why the “runaway convention” argument just can’t stand up to scrutiny, we invite you to read “Deconstructing the Con-Con Controversy” from our September 2024 issue.
The Bitterroot Star published an op-ed in support of an Article V Convention submitted by Helen Sabin.
Rita Peters, Senior Vice President for Legislative Affairs at Convention of States Action, penned a comprehensive rebuttal to an op-ed that ran in The Hill in September.
Former Senator Rick Santorum will speak on “Restoring America Through Article V of the US Constitution” in Rapid City, SD on November 12.
Article V Legislative Activity
Editor’s note: most states have been in recess. No Article V legislation has moved this month.
Article V Legislative Activity
Convention of States Project
- Illinois: SJR 27 and HJR 15 remain pending in their respective committees. The House version has bipartisan support.
- Ohio: SJR 3 and HJR 2 remain pending in their respective committees.
- Pennsylvania: HR 125 remains pending the House State Government Committee. The measure includes delegate selection and oversight language and has bipartisan support.
Countermand
- Pennsylvania: SR 118 remains pending in the State Government Committee. The legislation also contains language pertinent to delegates, so it is also included in the DSO list below.
Equal Rights Amendment
- Florida: S 82 has been prefiled.
- North Carolina: S 438 and H 500 remain pending in their respective committees.
Fiscal Responsibility
- United States: HCR 15 remains pending in committee.
Free and Fair Elections (Wolf Pack)
There is no Wolf Pack legislation active at this time.
Term Limits
- United States Congress: HJR 12 and SJR 1 remain pending in their respective committees. The House rendition has bipartisan support.
- United States Congress: HJR 29, allowing the president to serve a third term under certain circumstances, remains pending in Judiciary.
- Georgia: SR 23 continues to await action in the House Rules Committee.
- Pennsylvania: HR 21 continues to await a hearing in the State Government Committee. The measure covers Supreme Court justices as well as members of Congress and has bipartisan support.
Delegate Selection and Oversight
- New York: A 8935 remains pending in the Governmental Operations Committee.
- North Carolina: H 214 remains pending in the Committee on Rules and Operations of the Senate.
- Ohio: HB 67 and SB112 continue to await action in their respective committees.
- Pennsylvania: SR 117, specific to a convention to propose a countermand amendment, has been introduced and assigned to committee (see also Countermand legislation, above).
Rescission
California passed SJR 1, rescinding all prior applications for an Article V Convention.
Other
Oklahoma: HJR 1036, HJR 1036, prohibiting the President or any member of the House, Senate, or Supreme Court from being paid during a government shutdown, has been prefiled.
Constitutional Education
Does developing knowledge of the Constitution seem overwhelming? This month, take six-and-a-half minutes to hear from Justices Neil Gorsuch and Stephen Breyer (retired) on “Why read the founding documents?”
Who Said it?
The left vs. right stuff is actually not as important as the top vs bottom stuff.
State Representative James Talarico (D-Texas)