MONTHLY NEWSLETTER

Democratic Socialists of America: Spoiler or the Democratic Party of the Future?

Vickie Deppe

As of this writing, a half-dozen DSA members have won Congressional primaries. In November, they will join other democratic socialists who are not affiliated with the DSA—as well as candidates for state and local offices—on the ballot. Their more mainstream counterparts typically respond to press inquiries with “big tent” verbiage; but writing for USA Today, James Zirin maintains that whether they’re tied to the DSA or not, “democratic socialists are a gift to MAGA … [and] might be the thing that costs them the majority.” Newsweek cites Republican consultant Matt Klink: “Independent voters who might overlook high prices won’t give their trust to a political party that looks like it’s being run by its most radical wing.”

Why does this handful of political aspirants—vying for what amounts to little more than 1% of the seats up for grabs—command so much attention, speculation, and anxiety? In a word, federalism … or more accurately, our abandonment of it. The 10th Amendment explains that “the powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” Beginning in the 1930s, a more expansive understanding of the phrase “general welfare” led to ever-growing—and now virtually unlimited—objects and levels of federal spending, rendering the enumerated powers virtually meaningless.

This transition from local control to comprehensive, one-size-fits-all federal intervention—from the largest metropolitan areas to the smallest rural towns—has shifted the focus of federal elections from matters like foreign relations, monetary policy, the military, patents, and the postal service to the micromanagement of every conceivable facet of American life. According to Shameema Rahman, Senior Legal research Specialist in the Public Services Division of the Library of Congress, it’s “nearly impossible” to even estimate the number of federal laws found in the nearly 23,000 pages of the criminal code … and this doesn’t even include case law or laws written by regulatory agencies. For the few remaining areas of governance in which the federal government has yet to find a constitutional justification for insinuating itself, federal block grants are used to extort desired behavior from states and localities.

The reason there is outsized interest in this small handful of congressional candidates is because Congress exercises outsized control in the lives of everyday Americans. And to be fair, this concern isn’t isolated to conservatives: it happens on the left when far-right candidates win elections, too. But the real divide isn’t left vs. right: it’s DC power brokers vs. the rest of us. The states have the power to remedy this problem using their authority to propose amendments at an Article V Convention. They ought to use it.



Article V News 

The House Budget Committee has released a statement regarding Congressman Jodey Arrington’s call for an Article V Convention to address federal spending.

On October 2nd and 3rd, Harvard Law School will host V the People. The conference will bring together scholars, legislators, and advocates—supporters and skeptics alike, from across the political spectrum—to examine the questions surrounding an Article V Convention: What role might a convention play in strengthening American democracy? Which amendments should be pursued? And can the Article V convention process be used responsibly, safely, and legitimately? Participants may register here. The Caucus Newsletter will share links to streamed and/or recorded content as they become available.

Convention of States Project and the John Birch Society duke it out from their respective websites.

Wall Builders posted How Article V Amendments Really Work and Why 38 States Matter.


Article V Legislative Activity

Convention of States Project

  • Massachusetts: HB 5422 remains pending in the Rules Committee.
  • Michigan: HCR 7 remains pending in the Senate Government Operations Committee.
  • New Jersey: SCR 32 remains pending in the Senate State Government, Wagering, Tourism, and Historic Preservation Committee. The measure has bipartisan support.
  • Ohio: SJR 3 and HJR 2 remain pending in their respective committees.
  • Pennsylvania: HR 125 remains pending in the House State Government Committee. The measure includes delegate selection and oversight language and has bipartisan support.

Countermand

  • Pennsylvania: SR 118 remains pending in the State Government Committee. The legislation also contains language pertinent to delegates, so it is also included in the DSO list below.

Equal Rights Amendment

  • North Carolina: S 438 and H 500 remain pending in their respective committees.

Fiscal Responsibility

  • United States: HCR 15 remains pending in the House Judiciary Committee.
  • South Carolina: S 1164 remains pending in the Judiciary Committee. In addition to applying for the convention, it provides for state action if Congress fails to act on the call and offers Charleston, SC as host.

Free and Fair Elections (Wolf Pack)

  • Massachusetts: H 5422, H 5466, and S 2784 remain pending in thier respective Rules Committees.

Term Limits

  • United States Congress: HJR 12 and SJR 1 continue to remain pending in their respective committees. The House rendition has bipartisan support.
  • United States Congress: HJR 29, allowing the president to serve a third term under certain circumstances, continues to remain pending in Judiciary.
  • Pennsylvania: HR 21 continues to await a hearing in the State Government Committee. The measure covers Supreme Court justices as well as members of Congress and has bipartisan support.

Delegate Selection and Oversight

  • Michigan: HCR 2 and HB 5151 have been reported out of committee with recommendation and without amendment. Both await second reading.
  • New Jersey: S 832 continues to await action in the Senate State Government, Wagering, Tourism, and Historic Preservation Committee.
  • North Carolina: H 214 continues to await action in the Committee on Rules and Operations of the Senate.
  • Ohio: HB 67 and SB112 continue to await action in their respective committees.
  • Pennsylvania: SR 117 continues to await action in the State Government Committee (see also Countermand legislation, above).
  • South Carolina: S 1163 continues to await a hearing in the Senate Judiciary Committee.

Compact for a Safe and Equal Convention for Proposing Constitutional Amendments

  • South Carolina: S 1165 continues to await action in the Judiciary Committee.

Rescission

  • Alaska: HJR 41 continues to await action in the Judiciary Committee.

Other

New Jersey: SCR 22, applying for a convention to propose a balanced budget amendment, a term limits amendment, and unspecified changes to the allocation of Electoral College votes, continues to await a hearing in the Senate State Government, Wagering, Tourism, and Historic Preservation Committee.


Constitutional Education

Constituting America 250 will live stream The Constitution—How & Why It Matters on Constitution Day, September 17 from 1:00-2:30 ET.



Who Said it?

If there is any one secret of success it lies in the ability to get the other person’s point of view and see things from their angle as well as your own.

Henry Ford